1979, more than just the Family

1979, more than just the Family

     1979 will be remembered by many as the “We Are Family” Pirates, named after the song of that name by Sister Sledge.

     The Pittsburgh Pirates, led by thirty-nine year old first baseman (and future Hall of Famer) Willie 'Pops' Stargell, won the World Series in seven games over the Baltimore Orioles.

     The playoffs featured new teams for the first time in three years. In previous years, the Dodgers, Yankees, Royals and Phillies had won their divisions.

     The season began with a strike by the Major League umpires. It was a strike in name only, as their union contract was in place through 1981. Instead, the umpires opted to not sign their individual contracts for the 1979 season.

     Two umpires did sign contracts, and each worked opening day, but decided to join their contemporaries on the picket lines, but were instructed to remain on the job for ten days, as they had to give the league advance notice.

     Umpires formed picket lines outside the stadiums, dressed in their uniforms. In some cities, this created issues. Namely, strong union cities like Pittsburgh and Detroit, where union members did not wish to cross the umpire picket lines. There was a game in Detroit that was almost canceled because none of the concession workers at Tiger Stadium wanted to cross, but the umpires there decided to end the line “in the best interest of the fans”.

     For the first time since 1963, Pete Rose took the field for a different team, joining the Philadelphia Phillies as a re-entry free agent. Rose was 'drafted' by thirteen teams, the most allowed by the rules of the day.

     The re-entry draft, baseball's first foray into Free Agency, allowed teams to draft the rights these re-entry players, or players who had played out their contract without renewing their option for the following season. No player was allowed to be drafted by more than the thirteen, or half of the existing major league clubs. Said player was then free to negotiate a contract, but only with those teams which drafted him.

     If a player was not drafted in the re-entry draft, or was drafted by two or less teams, then that player was free to sign with any team.

     Oh yeah, and at the time, a team was only allowed to sign three re-entry free agents per each season. It took several years for Baseball to get this figured out, dealing with compensation for the teams losing the free agents, the fact that the draft wasn't truly “free” agency, and the collusion that reared its ugly head at the end of the next decade.

     But Rose was the first pick in the re-entry draft (by the Mets, as the teams drafted in order of their finish at the end of the previous season). And he was drafted five times in the first round.

Pitcher Larry Gura, Jim Slaton and Elias Sosa were all drafted fourteen times, which was the allowed 13 teams, plus a claim by their existing teams. Rose and Tommy John (yes, the guy with the surgery) were drafted thirteen times, including their current teams.

    1979 also brought us the now infamous Disco Demolition Night at Comiskey Park. In a promotion where customers who brought a 'disco' record were allowed to get in for 98 cents for a doubleheader against the Tigers, the White Sox staff were anticipating upwards of twenty thousand fans. Over fifty thousand fans showed up, with many more trying to get in without tickets. Security was deployed to assist at the gates.

     Fans were supposed to drop off their records into neatly arranged drop boxes, but that wasn't happening. Fans were bringing them to their seats, and eventually, these were going airborne, being tossed onto the field of play.

     Rusty Staub, who was playing in the outfield for the Tigers that night, suggested that all the Tigers wear their batting helmets on the field. Record, empty liquor bottles (not full ones, of course) lighters and firecrackers were tossed onto the field, and the first game was stopped several times for cleanup.

The Tigers did win the first game.

     Between games, a local disc jockey planned to 'dynamite' the cases of disco records, which he did. With a thunderous roar, bone rattling concussion and a huge plume of smoke, those records that were turned in became obliterated. A did the patch in the outfield which was laid bare by the explosion.

With all available security guards watching the gates for intruders, there was nobody watching the fans, a large number of which stormed the smoke filled field. As many as 7,000 fans swarmed around the field. The bases were all stolen, as was the pitching rubber, home plate and several clumps of turf. Some people set records on fire, stole equipment from the dugout, and even climbed the foul poles.

The White Sox players, in preparation for the second game of the doubleheader, began to populate in the dugout, while pitcher Ken Kravec started warming up in the bullpen. After just a few minutes, Kravec and the White Sox barricaded themselves behind their locked clubhouse door. White Sox announcer Harry Caray stood at what was home plate and implored the fans to return to their seats, while the scoreboard begged the same.

      Half an hour after the initial explosion, Chicago police, dressed in full riot gear, stormed the field and dispersed the remaining stragglers on the field, arresting thirty-nine people in the process.

     After calm was restored, White Sox owner Bill Veeck wanted the second game to begin, but umpire crew chief Dave Phillips deemed the field unplayable, and postponed the second game.

     Tigers manager Sparky Anderson protested that decision by the umpire, and felt that the second game should, in fact, be forfeited to the Tigers. According to Sparky's claim, a game can only be postponed because of an Act of God. Since the White Sox were unable to control their fans, created a dangerous environment, and left the field in unplayable condition, Sparky argued, that the game must be ruled a forfeit.

     And Sparky was right. American league President (remember when we had those) ruled in favor of the Tigers, and forfeited the game to them.

     To date, that game is the last American League game to be forfeited.

     It was a busy year for Commissioner Bowie Kuhn. He began warning of the looming economic collapse of baseball, due to the excessive contracts being doled out by a few clubs. The term “small-market team” was not a part of the vocabulary of the game as of yet, but Kuhn recognized the problem of the Yankees (yes he called them out for it) doling out big money contracts, compared to the A's (yes, he called them out as well) who were in a position of having to sell players for cash in order to keep themselves afloat.

     Changes were indeed on the horizon to get these sorted out, but the groundwork was in place for the 1981 mid-season strike.

     Kuhn did step in to several issues, acting in the 'best interest of baseball' as was his charge. As such, his biggest headline (and headache) was caused by the banning of Willie Mays from baseball. Followed by the same treatment for Mickey Mantle a few days later.

     Mays who was earning $50,000 per year from the Mets as a part-time coach and 'good will ambassador' was offered a similar position with the Bally's Casino in Atlantic City. Kuhn notified Mays that accepting the Bally's contract would promote gambling, and as such he would need to disassociate from the Mets.

     Mays signed with Bally's, and although he was no longer permitted to work for the Mets (or the Giants), he was still allowed to participate in Old Timer's games and their subsequent festivities. Mickey Mantle would enter the same deal with Bally's, with the same restrictions. Both of these deals were brokered by Hall of Famer, and former Yankees president Al Rosen. But more on him a bit later.

The commissioner also had to nullify a trade that the Yankees made with the Texas Rangers. On July 30^th, the Yankees sent speedy outfielder (my mom's favorite player) Mickey Rivers to the Rangers in exchange for four players. Unfortunately, the Rangers had failed to get waivers on two of the four players, so Kuhn voided the trade. Also unfortunately, Rivers had already appeared in a game for the Rangers, so the deal had to be restructured immediately, with Kuhn having the final say. It was re-worked with Oscar Gamble returning to the Bronx forty-eight hours later.

     Two sets of brothers had some interesting feats in 1979. Ken Forsch of the Houston Astros threw a no-hitter against Atlanta on April 7^th. It was the earliest no-hitter ever pitched at the time. (Hideo Nomo would pitch one on April 4, 2001. Ken's younger brother Bob pitched a no-no against the Phillies on April 16^th, 1978. This makes them the first brothers to have each pitched a no-hitter.

     Tom Underwood of the Blue Jays was tagged with the loss in two 1-0 games during the season. The first loss to Rick Waits and the Indians on May 14^th. The second, and historic in a quirky sort of way, was to the Tigers and Pat Underwood, on May 31^st. Pat Underwood, Tom's younger brother, made his major league debut in this game, and it was the first time in history that a pitcher made his debut pitching against his brother.

     Of the two Underwood brothers, Tom had the longer career, lasting eleven years, and winning eighty-six games. Pat pitched in parts of four seasons, winning thirteen games.

     Another curiosity was the Bob Watson, who incidentally scored baseball's millionth run in 1975, became the first player to hit for the cycle in each league.(John Olerud and Michael Cuddyer have done it since.)

     Hitting for the cycle consist of a batter hitting a single, double, triple and home run in the same game. It is rarer than a no-hitter. In fact, as of this writing, there have been 295 no-hitters and 263 cycles.

     

     In Chicago, the White Sox employed Don Kessinger as the teams manager. He was also their shortstop, appearing in 54 games before he resigned in early August. He was replaced by former infielder, and law student Tony LaRussa, who had been managing at Iowa. LaRussa would pass the bar exam in the off-season, and would go on to a Hall of Fame career as a manager.

     George Brett accomplished the rare feat of hitting 20 or more doubles, triples and home runs in a season. How rare you ask? He was the fourth to do it. Prior to Brett in 1979, Sunny Jim Bottomley did it in 1928, Jeff Heath in 1941 and Willie Mays in 1957. In a weird quirk, and baseball is full of those, Curtis Granderson and Jimmy Rollins both did it in 2007.

     Speaking of the Royals, they finished in second place in the AL West, but had four players each score 100 or more runs: Brett, Darrell Porter, Willie Wilson and Amos Otis.

And across the state, Garry Templeton of the Cardinals led the league with 211 hits. Historic in that the switch-hitting shortstop was the first player to get 100 hits from each side of the plate in a season.

     In Houston, shortstop Craig Reynolds had 34 Sacrifice Hits, the most in the National League since Dick Bartell had 37 in 1933. Bert “Campy” Campaneris had 40 for the Rangers in 1977.

And the Twins had two players with 20 of more sacrifices that year, Rookie of the Year John Castino had 22, and Rob Wilfong had 25.

     The June amateur draft for 1979 resulted in some unique and infamous draftees. Some had referred to that draft as the “Year of the Quarterbacks”, since the Kansas City Royals drafted two Hall of Fame Quarterbacks in the early rounds of the draft. With their fourth round pick, they drafted pitcher Dan Marino out of Central Catholic High School in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. And with their eighteenth round pick, they drafted outfielder John Elway from Grenada Hills High School in Northridge, California. Neither of them signed that season, and while Elway was later drafted and signed by the Yankees, they both became legendary NFL players.

     Incidentally, with the third pick in the first round, Toronto drafted catcher Jay Schroeder from Palisades high School in Pacific Palisades, California. Schroeder would quarterback the Washington Redskins to a victory in Super Bowl XXII over the Denver Broncos (and John Elway).

     In minor league news, a new minor league, playing at the Triple A level, debuted in 1979. The Inter-American League was based in and around the Caribbean, with teams in Miami. Caracas, Santo Domingo, Panama and Puerto Rico. They featured more seasoned players, with the average age being 27.6 years old, whereas the other three AAA leagues average age was 25 years old.

The league featured a few former major leaguers of some repute. Players like Dave May, Mike Kekich and Cesar Tovar to name a few. Davey Johnson managed the Miami Amigos to 51-21 record before the league folded. The main issues that caused the league to disband were 'monsoonal rains' and unreliable air travel.

     Mark “Boom Boom” Bomback of the Vancouver Canadians, the AAA affiliate of the Brewers, led minor league baseball with 22 wins that year. Bomback would be traded to the Mets for pitcher Dwight Bernard after the season.

     In the Bronx, there was turmoil and tragedy.

     Turmoil in the revolving door that was management. Bob Lemon, who led the team to the World Championship in 1978, and was hired as a calming influence after the tempestuous Billy Martin was fired, was himself fired on June 18^th. Lemon was replaced by Billy Martin, whose (I guess) tempestuous influence was needed to change the calm that was the Yankees clubhouse.

(Martin would be fired after the season, mainly because of a fight in a bra with a marshmallow salesman. Yes. Marshmallows)

     Al Rosen, the Yankees president stepped down after being essentially stripped of power and influence over the baseball operations of the team. The constant criticism and second guessing from the Yankees owner was also a big factor in his decision.

The final straw for Rosen came after the ABC network asked to reschedule a game in Anaheim against the Angels in July, changing the start time from 7:30 local time to 5:30, to accommodate a national broadcast.

     As fate would have it, the twilight game featured Nolan Ryan pitching against the Yankees, who were one-hit in a 6-1 loss. The Yankees owner exploded, blaming Rosen wholly for the defeat. Rosen stepped down shortly afterward to accept the job with Bally's. That brought the number of Yankees executive who had stepped down under the new ownership to twelve. With many more to come.

     Early in the season, after some good natured ribbing took an ugly turn, catcher Cliff Johnson and pitcher Rich Gossage got into a fistfight in the clubhouse. Neither of the two combatants were what you would call small,. Johnson at 6'4 215 and Gossage at 6'3 180. The scuffle caused Gossage to tear a ligament in the thumb of his throwing hand, which needed surgery. Gossage missed more than two months. Johnson was traded (banished?) to Cleveland at the June 15^th trading deadline.

     Later in the season, when the Yankees were playing in Cleveland, Billy Martin is alleged to have instructed rookie pitcher bob Kammeyer to drill Johnson with a pitch, which he did. Martin handed Kammeyer $100 in the dugout upon his return. Martin later said that that money was not a reward, rather it was money to pay for Kammeyer and two other rookie pitcher out to dinner that night.

The AL President investigated, but ruled in Martin's favor. Saying that there was no doubt that a brush-back pitch was thrown, that there was no intent to hit Johnson.

      Tragedy in the Bronx began in spring training, when beloved coach Elston Howard was diagnosed with a virus infection around his heart. He was hospitalized for several weeks, and was unable to be in uniform at all that season.

     However, the biggest tragedy of the season, and not just for the Yankees, was the surprising death of Yankee Captain Thurman Munson.

     On August 2^nd, a Yankee off-day, Munson was practicing landings with his new Cessna Citation. Munson crashed the plane 1,000 feet short of the runway, and the plane burst into flames. Two passengers in the jet were able to make it out, but were unable to rescue Munson, who perished.

     The Yankees played the Orioles at Yankee Stadium the following night, with the eight Yankee fielders taking their position, leaving the catcher's spot empty. At the conclusion of the pre-game ceremonies, which included a prayer from Terence Cardinal Cooke, and opera star Robert Merrill singing “America, the Beautiful”, the 51,151 in attendance gave a thunderous ovation that lasted for 9 minutes, as the scoreboard showed Munson's picture and listed his career highlights.

     The Yankees announced that they would retire his number 15 immediately, and left his locker empty.

But now to the season at hand...

First, the power rankings were:

1. Baltimore AL Champs
2. Pittsburgh World Series Champs
3. Montreal 2^nd in NL East
4. Boston 3^rd in AL East
5. Milwaukee 2^nd in NL East

     The Orioles won the American League Eastern Division tile, and beat the Western Division Champion California Angels in the playoffs. This was the Angels first post-season appearance, And the Pirates, who won the National League East bested the Cincinnati Reds, who won the Western Division in their series.

     And as I mentioned above, the Pirates bested the Orioles in what has been described as the coldest World Series on record. There was one game postponed by rain, and a couple of more delayed due to the weather. Willie Stargell was the MVP of the World Series, most notably for his leadership, but he also hit .400 for the Series, and hit the only three homers hit by Pittsburgh. His leadership was pointed to all season, and as a result, he was named a co-MVP for the National League.

     Unfortunately, that leadership, like fielding, had to be noted anecdotally, as there is no true way to measure that numerically, and is totally subjective.

     Yes...fielding is subjective. Especially in the game as it is played today. With the defensive shifts being employed, traditional scoring almost goes out the window. For example, lets say there is a left-handed pull hitter up, and the defense aligns to match his hitting tendencies, and he hits a grounder to the second base side of the infield, but it is fielded by the third baseman, playing on the right side because of the new alignment, who throws the batter out at first. Well the scoring for that play is 5-3. So now you have the third baseman getting an assist where he wouldn't have gotten one three years ago. This increases his fielding chances, and increases his 'range', which factors his fielding chances compared to other players at his position. The more chances over the par, the higher his 'range' is, in theory getting to mare balls makes him a better fielder. But does it really?

     Conversely, in the same example as above, the batter goes the other way, and hits it to the left side of the infield, where the shortstop has to go much farther to his right, since there is no third baseman in position, overextends himself, and makes a bad throw that pulls the first baseman off the bag, resulting in a throwing error for the shortstop. The negative impact on the shortstops fielding percentage is obvious. But also, let's say he decided to let that ball through, which takes a defensive chance away from him, especially if it was a ball hit where he would have been playing in a traditional defensive alignment.

     And offensively, if the batter from above begins accumulating a few 5-3 at bats, the scouting reports may tip back to his being a spray hitter, since he's grounding out to the third baseman.

     OK...where was I? Oh yeah, the 1979 season.

Looking at the National League hitters, raw numbers first:

Player	Team	HR	RBI	AVG	Runs/G
Dave Kingman	Cubs	48	115	.288	1.13
Keith Hernandez	Cardinals	11	105	.344	1.30
Ted Simmons	Cardinals	26	87	.283	1.05
Dave Winfield	Padres	34	118	.308	1.14
Mike Schmidt	Phillies	45	114	.253	1.11
George Foster	Reds	30	98	.302	1.12
Dave Parker	Pirates	25	94	.310	1.13
Johnny Bench	Red	22	80	.276	1.01
Bob Horner	Braves	33	98	.314	1.08
Steve Garvey	Dodgers	28	110	.315	1.07
Willie Stargell	Pirates	32	82	.281	0.87

     I added Willie Stargell as a comparison...

Next, we'll look to see the best performers over their team's average:

Dave Winfield	above
Dave Kingman	above
Mike Schmidt	above
Keith Hernandez	above
Bob Horner	above
Ted Simmons	above
Lee Mazzilli	Mets	15	79	.303	0.90
Jack Clark	Giants	26	86	.273	1.03
Gary Matthews	Braves	27	90	.304	1.03
Johnny Bench	above

     So combing and crunching, our top National League offensive players, with their post-season voting results are as follows:

Dave Kingman                                         11^th in MVP

Dave Winfield                                          3^rd in MVP

Keith Hernandez                                      tied for 1^st in MVP

Mike Schmidt                                           13^th in MVP

Ted Simmons                                            no votes

George Foster                                           12^th in MVP

Bob Horner                                               28^th in MVP

Johnny Bench                                           23^rd in MVP

Dave Parker                                              10^th in MVP

Gary Matthews                                         26^th in MVP

     Now looking at the American League hitters, where the league performed as a whole 9% better than the National league, mainly due to the designated hitter rule, here are the top hitters raw numbers:

Fred Lynn	Red Sox	39	122	.333	1.35
Darrell Porter	Royals	20	112	.291	1.23
Jim Rice	Red Sox	39	130	.325	1.32
Don Baylor	Angels	36	139	.296	1.38
George Brett	Royals	23	107	.329	1.32
Steve Kemp	Tigers	26	105	.318	1.25
Sixto Lezcano	Brewers	28	101	.321	1.14
Brian Downing	Angels	12	75	.326	1.01
Dan Ford	Angels	21	101	.290	1.27
Gorman Thomas	Brewers	45	123	.244	1.12

Then looking at their team averages, we get:

Dave Revering	A's	19	77	.288	0.97
Steve Kemp	above
Fred Lynn	above
Bruce Bochte	Mariners	16	100	.316	1.10
Darrell Porter	above
John Mayberry	Blue Jays	21	74	.274	0.83
Reggie Jackson	Yankees	29	89	.297	1.05
Sixto Lezcano	above
Don Baylor	above
Ken Singleton	Orioles	35	111	.295	1.06

     So, that being said, our top American League offensive players, along with their post-season voting results are as follows:

Fred Lynn                              4^th in MVP

Darrell Porter                         9^th in MVP

Steve Kemp                           17^th in MVP

Don Baylor                            1^st in MVP

Jim Rice                                5^th in MVP

George Brett                          3^rd in MVP

Sixto Lezcano                       15^th in MVP

Dave Revering                      no votes

Bruce Bochte                        no votes

Ken Singleton                       2^nd in MVP

     Sixto Lezcano, as I have mentioned in previous posts, and will mention again, has one of the oddest coincidences in the annals of baseball. He was traded at one time in a deal that included pitcher Steve Fireovid. Steve Fireovid had the distinction of having six toes on each foot. So essentially, Six-toed Steve Fireovid was traded for Sixto Lezcano.

How about that.

     So, speaking of pitching, we'll look at the National League pitchers first, as they performed 6% better on average than their American League counterparts, the top performers initially were:

Pitcher	Team	W-L	Save	ERA
Joe Niekro	Astros	21-11	0	3.00
J. R. Richard	Astros	18-13	0	2.71
Bruce Sutter	Cubs	6-6	37	2.22
Tom Seaver	Reds	16-6	0	3.14
Bill Lee	Expos	16-10	0	3.04
Joe Sambito	Astros	8-7	22	1.77
Ken Forsch	Astros	11-6	0	3.04
Steve Carlton	Phillies	18-11	0	3.62
Elias Sosa	Expos	8-7	18	1.96
Sylvio Martinez	Cardinals	15-8	0	3.27

And compared to their teams averages, we get:

Phil Niekro	Braves	21-20	0	3.39
Bruce Sutter	above
Craig Swan	Mets	14-13	0	3.29
Steve Carlton	above
Greg Minton	Giants	4-3	4	1.81
Tom Seaver	above
Gaylord Perry	Padres	12-11	0	3.06
Joey McLaughlin	Braves	5-3	5	2.48
Gary Lavelle	Giants	7-9	20	2.51
Joe Niekro	above

     So crunching and auditing brings us these top ten National League pitching performance:

Bruce Sutter                      Cy Young Winner, 7^th in MVP

Phil Niekro                        6^th in Cy Young

Tom Seaver                        4^th in Cy Young, 21^st in MVP (tied)

Joe Niekro                          2^nd in Cy Young, 6^th in MVP

J. R. Richard                      3^rd in Cy Young, 19^th in MVP

Steve Carlton                     no votes

Craig Swan                        no votes

Joe Sambito                       21^st in MVP (tied)

Sylvio Martinez                 no votes

Gaylord Perry                    no votes

And the American League initial performers were:

Ron Guidry	Yankees	18-8	2	2.78
Jack Morris	Tigers	17-7	0	3.28
Jim Kern	Rangers	13-5	29	1.57
Mike Flanagan	Orioles	23-9	0	3.08
Tommy John	Yankees	21-9	0	2.96
Dennis Eckersley	Red Sox	17-10	0	2.99
Mike Caldwell	Brewers	16-6	0	3.29
Jerry Koosman	Twins	20-13	0	3.38
Scott McGregor	Orioles	13-6	0	3.35
Ron Davis	Yankees	14-2	9	2.85

And against their teams, we get:

Tom Underwood	Blue Jays	9-16	0	3.69
Jack Morris	above
Tom Buskey	Blue Jays	06-10	7	3.43
Rick Langford	A's	12-16	0	4.28
Jim Kern	above
Ron Guidry	above
Steve McCatty	A's	11-12	0	4.22
Jerry Koosman	above
Tommy John	above
Dennis Eckersley	above

     So that makes our final listing, the top pitchers in the American League as follows:

Ron Guidry                    3^rd in Cy Young, 26^th in MVP

Jack Morris                    no votes

Jim Kern                        4^th in Cy Young, 11^th in MVP

Tommy John                  2^nd in Cy Young, 22^nd in MVP

Dennis Eckersley           7^th in Cy Young (tie)

Jerry Koosman               6^th in Cy Young

Mike Flanagan               Cy Young Winner

Mike Caldwell               no votes

Aurelio Lopes (Tigers)   7^th in Cy Young (tie) 10-5 2.41, 21 saves

Geoff Zahn (Angels)      no votes 13-7 3.57

     As I mentioned earlier, there is no real tangible number that can be placed on leadership. There is no doubt that Willie Stargell was the spiritual and emotional leader of the Pirates, as he led them to the World Series championship. And I don't mean to diminish that accomplishment. But in looking at the numbers, and only at the numbers, were I to have voted in that post season ballot, he would have not received one of my ten votes.

     In fact, of the post season awards given out in 1979, I would only agree with one of them. The choice of Cubs relief ace Bruce Sutter. And even though the Cubs finished under .500 for the year, and were eighteen games out of first place, Dave Kingman would have been my best offensive player vote. Whether that translates to the most valuable player is an ongoing conversation. But Kingman outperformed the league, as well as his team.

The official awards given that fall went to:

Willie Stargell NL co-MVP

Keith Hernandez NL co-MVP

Bruce Sutter NL Cy Young

Don Baylor AL MVP

Mike Flanagan AL Cy Young

While my awards are

Dave Kingman NL Player

Bruce Sutter NL Pitcher

Fred Lynn AL Player

Ron Guidry AL Pitcher

thanks for reading...

1912, and the polarizing Ty Cobb

     Tyrus Raymond Cobb, a.k.a. The Georgia Peach, was well into his legendary baseball career by the time the 1912 season was played. This would be his sixth full big league season, and he already had won five or six batting titles. I say five or six because of the hi-jinks that occurred at the conclusion of the 1910 season.

     While the dispute had been settled quite some time ago, there was a span of several years when no one knew who was the official batting champion in the American League in 1910.

     Most baseball fans know how Cobb was not a very popular player during his career. Hated, despised and belligerent were words used to describe Cobb, in both his playing style and his overall demeanor.

     Towards the end of the 1910 season, Cobb and Napoleon Lajoie of the Indians were competing for the title, with Cobb in the lead by a few percentage points. Cobb, with the Tigers out of pennant contention, decided to sit out the last couple of games to keep his average atop the league, claiming an issue with his eyes. Cobb figured that the car was his at that point.

     The Chalmers Motor Company had announced that they would award to the batting champion, a brand new 'Chalmers 30' car. This was the beginning of the "Chalmers Award" that was to be awarded to the best player in each league. It was decided, also, that no player could win the award more than once. (This was one of the forerunners to the Most Valuable Player Award) That award was issued from 1911-1915 before

     Lajoie, who was playing in St. Louis against the Browns, noticed that in his first at bat that the Browns third-baseman was playing deep, and that a bunt might well result in a hit. That third-baseman, rookie Red Corriden, later explained that his manager had instructed him to play deep because a line drive from Lajoie might 'kill him'.

     That manager, Jack O'Connor, was a one time teammate of Lajoie.

     Lajoie, taking advantage of the defensive alignment, bunted safely six times that day, and also hit another infield single and a triple. He reached base on an error by the Browns' shortstop. According to reports, Browns coach Harry Howell sent a bat boy to the official scorer with the offer of a free suit if he changed the scoring of an error to a hit.

     The next day, unofficial final batting averages were published in the newspapers, and some showed Cobb as the champion, some showed Lajoie. In fact, eight members of the Tigers sent congratulatory telegrams to Lajoie. Tigers owner Frank Navin, as did many Cobb supporters, claimed foul, and got A.L. President Ban Johnson involved in the dispute. He found the there 'was nothing dishonest' in their actions, and cleared all parties.

     Howell and O'Connor were soon out of baseball, although I'm sure there were other reasons than this scandal. Corriden, a rookie, was absolved and went on to have a nice career.

     The Chalmers Motor Company announced that they would award a car to each of the two players.

When the Sporting News came out with the official averages days later, it put the controversy to rest, giving Cobb an average of .385 to Lajoie's .384.

     While doing research seventy years later, Sporting News historian discovered that Cobb was actually credited for the same game twice, giving Cobb two less hits than he was credited for in 1910, and in fact giving the batting title to Lajoie. Commissioner Bowie Kuhn agreed to alter Cobb's career hit total, but to not strip him of the batting title.

     Cobb's belligerent personality was never more evident than in the 1912 season.

     In May of that year, while in New York, Cobb got into a shouting match with a fan at the game. Cobb said later that the same man had taunted him on several occasions. Cobb snapped and went into the stands to attack the fan.

      The fan who had lost several fingers in an industrial accident was quickly knocked down by Cobb, who then began kicking and stomping on him, When someone yelled for Cobb to stop because, "He has no hands!"

     Cobb replied "I don't care if he has no feet!"

     Teammates and police officers were finally able to pull Cobb from the victim, and he was immediately tossed from the game, and immediately suspended indefinitely by Ban Johnson, who happened to be at Hilltop Park to witness the incident.

     The rest of the Tigers staged what was the very first player revolt in the American League. They refused to take the field two days later in Philadelphia in support of Cobb. The Tigers scrambled to field a team, rather than forfeit the game, and stocked the roster with a variety of semi-pro players that were available. (The Tigers would have faced a $5,000 fine if they were forced to forfeit)

     Manager Hughie Jennings (who would play in this game, along with two of his coaches), with the help of a Philadelphia sportswriter, was able to round up a collection of neighborhood players.                  Relying on Allan Travers, a seminary student and the promise of $25 for the game, the Tigers were able to take the field in what would be an historic feat.

     Travers, an outfielder by 'trade' discovered that the pitcher would earn $50, so he took the mound, and the loss in a 24-2 drubbing.

     As a curiosity, one of the players recruited by Travers was former boxer Billy Maharg, who would be a key conspirator in the 1919 Chicago Black Sox scandal a few years later. Maharg would lose a few teeth on a ground ball at third base.

     The Tigers owner petitioned Johnson to cancel any upcoming games until the strike was settled, but Johnson disagreed. Eventually, Cobb did ask his teammates to end the strike and resume play, which they did. The striking players were fined $100 each. Cobb was fined $50, but suspended for 10 games.

     Travers went back to the seminary, after his only big league appearance on that May afternoon. He completed his studies, and became a Jesuit priest, becoming the only priest to play in the major leagues. He would become a teacher at St. Francis Xavier High School in Manhattan, and would later become the Dean on Men at St. Joseph College in Philadelphia.

     But, back to Cobb.

     Then there was another incident in 1912 where three men attacked Cobb while he was driving with his wife in Detroit, in August of that year. Accounts vary as to what took place from this point on. One thing that is known is that one of the man did slash Cobb across the back with a knife. The rest of the story changes, ranging from Cobb pistol whipping one of the assailants, to Cobb killing one of the attackers. (This latter account was allegedly told to biographer Al Stump, but has never been able to be verified)

     Can you imagine if this happened in today's world, with 24-hour news cycles, and the preponderance of cell-phone cameras and social media? These incidents would be replayed on all the news programs, or the sports highlight shows, over and over.

     Instead, with the technology of the day in 1912, it would take days or weeks for these stories to become widely known.

     All this turmoil does not take away from the fact that Cobb had a phenomenal season, hitting .409 (or.410, depending on the source) for the sixth place Tigers. It was Cobb's second consecutive .400 season.

     Also in 1912:

     Fenway Park opened in Boston...

     Hugh Bradley of the Red Sox becomes the first to homer over the Green Monster at Fenway, his only home run of the season. He would hit just one more in a five year major league career...

     Navin Field (later Tiger Stadium) opened in Detroit...

     Crosley Field opened in Cincinnati...

     The New York Highlanders (soon to be Yankees) took the field wearing pinstriped jerseys for the first time...

     Rube Marquard won 19 games in a row...

     J. Owen “Chief” Wilson hits 36 triples, a record which still stands, and is one that will never be broken, in my opinion.

     Smoky Joe Wood and Walter Johnson each topped 30 wins; Wood with 34 and Johnson with 33...

     The Boston Red Sox won the World Series over the New York Giants, 4 games to 3. One game resulted in a tie. This marks the first time the World Series was decided in the last inning of the final game.

     

      On to the season at hand. There were six teams that won 90 or more games, three in each league. The Giants paced the National League, winning 103. And The Red Sox won 105 to claim the American League pennant.

The team rankings for 1912 were:

     New York Giants    NL Champions

     Boston Red Sox      World Champions

     Pittsburgh Pirates    2^nd Place, 10 games behind

     Washington Senators 2^nd place, 14 games behind

     Philadelphia A's      3^rd place, 15 games behind

     We'll analyze the National League pitching first, showing the raw rankings first, and instead or ERA, I will show Runs Allowed, again as the defensive tools were fairly primitive still:

Pitcher	Team	W-L	Runs
Christy Mathewson	Giants	23-12	3.11
Claude Hendrix	Pirates	24-9	3.43
Rube Marquard	Giants	26-11	3.42
Jeff Tesreau	Giants	17-7	3.33
Larry Cheney	Cubs	26-10	3.62
Nap Rucker	Dodgers	18-21	3.05
Howie Camnitz	Pirates	22-12	3.38
Hank Robinson	Pirates	12-7	2.78
Eppa Rixey	Phillies	10-10	3.17
George Suggs	Reds	19-16	3.92

And against their teams averages, we get this list:

Nap Rucker
Slim Sallee	St. Louis	16-17	3.73
Hub Perdue	Brooklyn	13-16	4.88
Otto Hess	Braves	12-17	5.03
Larry Cheney
Eppa Rixey
George Suggs
Claude Hendrix
Pete Alexander	Phillies	19-17	3.86
Art Fromme	Reds	16-18	3.83

And that gets us to our top performers for the season:

Christy Mathewson

Claude Hendrix

Rube Marquard

Jeff Tesreau

Nap Rucker

Hank Robinson

Larry Cheney

Howie Camnitz

Eppa Rixey

Marty O'Toole (Pirates, 15-17 3.60 Runs Avg)

     The pitching in the Senior Circuit was a little more consistent, but the Junior Circuit had some stand out performances. Statistically speaking, the AL had a 0.29% better ranking than the NL. We'll get into the hitting portion in a moment.

     As I mentioned earlier, there were two 30-game winners in the AL, and the following list is very top-heavy with great performances.

     Our raw rankings in the AL are:

Pitcher	Team	W-L	Runs
Joe Wood	Red Sox	34-5	2.72
Walter Johnson	Senators	33-12	2.17
Eddie Plank	Athletics	26-6	3.12
Ed Walsh	White Sox	27-17	2.86
Bob Groom	Senators	24-13	3.79
Vean Gregg	Cleveland	20-13	3.28
Buck O'Brien	Red Sox	20-13	3.49
Ray Collins	Red Sox	13-8	2.94
Chief Bender	Athletics	13-8	3.32
Hugh Bedient	Red Sox	20-9	3.62

And against their team's average performances:

George McConnell	New York Highlanders	8-12	4.89
Eddie Plank
Walter Johnson
Jack Warhop	Highlanders	10-19	4.22
Jean Dubuc	Tigers	17-10	3.85
Joe Wood
Russ Ford	Highlanders	13-21	5.09
Ed Walsh
Ed Willett	Tigers	17-15	4.56
George Baumgardner	Browns	11-13	4.16

And this brings us to the top performers list in the American League:

Walter Johnson

Smoky Joe Wood

Eddie Plank

Big Ed Walsh

Vean Gregg

Ray Collins

Buck O'Brien

Chief Bender

Bob Groom

Hugh Bedient

     Now, we'll take a look at the offense. In this realm, the National League hitters performed at a clip that was 5.68% better than in the American League.

Our initial performance numbers in the NL are:

Hitter	Team	HR	RBI	SB	AVG
Heinie Zimmerman	Cubs	14	104	23	.372
Honus Wagner	Pirates	7	101	26	.324
Larry Doyle	Giants	10	91	36	.330
Bill Sweeney	Braves	1	99	27	.344
Fred Merkle	Giants	11	88	37	.309
John Titus	Phillies/Braves	5	73	11	.309
Chief Meyer	Giants	6	60	8	.358
Max Carey	Pirates	5	68	45	.302
J. Owen Wilson	Pirates	11	94	16	.300
Ed Konetchy	Cardinals	8	82	25	.314

And then comparing against team performances, we get this:

Heinie Zimmerman
John Ttitus
Bill Sweeney
Ed Konetchy
Honus Wagner
Sherry Magee	Phillies	6	66	30	.290
Zack Wheat	Dodgers	8	65	16	.305
Bob Bescher	Reds	4	38	67	.281
Dick Hoblitzel	Reds	2	85	23	.294
Dode Paskert	Phillies	2	43	36	.315

Which gets us to our leaders:

Heinie Zimmerman

Honus Wagner

Bill Sweeney

John Titus

Ed Konetchy

Larry Doyle

Sherry Magee

Zack Wheat

Fred Merkle

Bob Bescher

And then the American League raw numbers are:

Hitter	Team	HR	RBI	SB	AVG
Frank “Home Run” Baker	Athletics	10	130	40	.347
Tris Speaker	Red Sox	10	90	52	.383
Ty Cobb	Tigers	7	83	61	.409
“Shoeless” Joe Jackson	Cleveland	3	90	35	.395
Nap Lajoie	Cleveland	0	90	18	.368
Eddie Collins	Athletics	0	64	63	.348
Sam Crawford	Tigers	4	109	42	.325
Larry Gardner	Red Sox	3	86	25	.315
Stuffy McInnis	Athletics	3	101	27	.327
Duffy Lewis	Red Sox	6	109	9	.284

And against their teams, we get:

Joe Jackson
Ty Cobb
Frank Baker
Nap Lajoie
Tris Speaker
Del Pratt	Browns	5	69	24	.302
Sam Crawford
Eddie Collins
Chick Gandil	Senators	2	81	19	.305
Clyde Milan	Senators	1	79	88	.306

So our overall ratings for American League hitters is:

Ty Cobb

Joe Jackson

Frank Baker

Tris Speaker

Nap Lajoie

Eddie Collins

Sam Crawford

Chick Gandil

Clyde Milan

Stuffy McInnis

     This was the second year of the “Chalmers Award”, which was voted on and awarded to the best player in each league. The award didn't generate as much publicity for the Chalmers Motor Company, so it was discontinued after the 1914 season.

     I discussed earlier on the Chalmers company giving a car to Cobb and Lajoie after the 1910 season. In 1911, the winners were Ty Cobb and Frank Schulte of the Cubs.

In 1912, the top five in voting for the award went as follows:

National League

1. Larry Doyle    
   
2. Honus Wagner
3. Chief Meyers
4. Joe Tinker
5. Bob Bescher

American League

1. Tris Speaker  
   
2. Ed Walsh
3. Walter Johnson
4. Clyde Milan
5. Smoky Joe Wood

     So, were I a voter at that time, and was voting for overall best player in each league, as well as best pitcher in each league, her is how that vote would be:

National League:

1. Christy Mathewson (12^th in Chalmers vote)  
   
2. Heinie Zimmerman (6^th)
3. Claude Hendrix (20^th)
4. Rube Marquard (8^th)
5. Honus Wagner

American League:

1. Walter Johnson  
   
2. Joe Wood
3. Ty Cobb (tied for 7^th)
4. Joe Jackson (9^th)
5. Frank Baker (tied for 7^th)

     Again, while the hitters were a little more dominant in the National League, the pitching performances of Christy Mathewson was just a bit more dominant.

     Heinie Zimmerman of the Cubs had a great season, even if he is one of the forgotten players of that era. 1912 would be his best season by far. He drove in 100 runs only one other time, and although he finished with a .295 career average, he never led the league in batting again.