Wednesday, December 21, 2016

1903, The Dawning of a Legacy...


     Immediately prior to the 1903 season, the National League pondered its future. With the upstart American League's success in attendance and player poaching, there was talk of a merger between the two leagues which would have resulted in one twelve team league. Instead, a truce was declared, and the two leagues worked together, but still maintained their own identities.
     As a way to smooth ruffled feathers, both leagues decided to participate in a Championship Series between the champion of each league. The best-of-nine series featured the Boston Americans faced the Pittsburgh Pirates in the first “World Series”. The Pirates, who lost Ed Doheny late in the season due to a 'mental breakdown' combined with an injury to pitcher Sam Leever, left their pitching thin, as they lost the inaugural series to Boston.
     Boston starter Bill Dineen won three games, and Cy Young the other two. Pirated hurler Deacon Phillipe pitched a record five complete games during the series.

     Off the field, one of the oddest tragedies befell Washington Senator outfielder Ed Delahanty.
     On July 2nd, he was ejected from a train due to drunkenness. Some reports have him brandishing a straight razor and threatening other passengers after 'consuming five whiskeys'.
     He attempted to cross the International Bridge, when he either fell, jumped or was pushed off the bridge. It is not known whether he perished due to the fall, or if he drowned. His body was found two weeks after his disappearance.
     One of the best hitter of his generation, and one of five Delahanty brothers who played major league baseball, he finished with a career batting average of .346, and just under 2,600 career base hits. At the time of his passing, he was second on the all-time hits list.

     He was inducted to the Hall of Fame in 1945 by the Veteran's Committee.

     On the field, several standout performances took place.

     The Baltimore Orioles team folded, and the franchise was sold and moved to New York, where they began play as the New York Highlanders. Major League baseball would return to Baltimore in 1954. During that lapse, the Baltimore team in the International League flourished, and is said to have had some of the best minor league teams of that era. Remember, babe Ruth got his start playing for his hometown team in 1914.

     In May, the White Sox committed twelve errors in a game against the Tigers, while the Tigers themselves committed six themselves, in what is referred to as the “18-E Debacle”, which still stands as the most errors in a single game.
     Speaking of the Tigers, Outfielder “Wahoo” Sam Crawford led the league in triples with 25, which establishing a record that would stand until 1912. It was his first of a record five triples championships.

     The Cleveland Bluebirds (shortened to Blues) changed their name to the Cleveland Napoleons (shortened to Naps) in honor of their star player, Napoleon Lajoie, who was purchased from the Philadelphia Athletics. Lajoie was originally a Philadelphia Phillie, but jumped to the Athletics for more money during the formation of the American League. Lawsuits and injunctions made it not possible for the Athletics to play Lajoie in Philadelphia, so owner Connie Mack sold Lajoie to Cleveland for a reported $25,000. Lajoie continued to sit out games played in Philadelphia.

     In September, Cleveland Naps pitcher Jesse Stovall made his first career start, and pitched an eleven-inning shutout against the Tigers, which remains the longest shutout by a pitcher starting his first game.

     Also for the Naps, Bill Bradley established a still record for third baseman for hitting 22 triples in a season.

     For the Philadelphia Athletics, pitcher Rube Waddell became the first to strike out 300 batters in a season. He would become the first to do so in consecutive seasons, when he established a long standing record of 349 strikeouts in 1904.

     In Chicago, the Orphans became the Cubs. Catcher Johnny Kling set a record for triples hit by a catcher, with 13. Tim McCarver would tie that record in 1966.

     Frank Chance established a still standing record of 67 stolen bases by a first baseman, 
and pitcher Jake Weimer was one of two rookies to win twenty games.



     Henry Schmidt of the Brooklyn Superbas was the other rookie to win twenty games. It was his only season in the majors, and he is the only player to win twenty games in his only season in the majors.

     Jimmy Sheckard of Brooklyn hit nine homers to lead the league. His homers accounted for 60% of the team's total. He also established the record for most stolen bases by the home run champ with 67. At the time, Sheckard and Frank Chance established a new record for stolen bases, bested by Bob Bescher in 1910.

     For the Cardinals, Homer Smoot hit four home runs. This was exactly half of the Cardinals' eight homers for the season.

   
     In Pittsburgh, Player-Manager Fred Clarke became the first player in the modern era (1901-) to hit for the cycle twice.

     Pitcher Sam Leever became the first National League pitcher to lead the league in ERA with twenty-five or more wins.

     Honus Wagner won his second (of eight) batting titles, and was the first to lead in batting while striking out less than twenty times during the season. He struck out just seventeen times, and in a true case of baseball irony, Wagner struck out to end the World Series.

     Wagner and Cleveland's Nap Lajoie led their leagues in batting, marking the first time that two right handed batters led each league in that category.


     For the Boston Americans (soon to be Red Sox) Buck Freeman was the first in franchise history to hit for the cycle, and to lead the league in home runs.

     The New York Giants pitching was top notch. They had two thirty-game winners, yet still failed to win the pennant. In fact, Joe McGinnity and Christy Mathewson combined for sixty-one wins, which was 72.6% of the team's eighty-four victories.
     The Giants bettered their 1902 season by winning thirty-six more games.
     Christy Mathewson began a streak of twelve straight years of winning twenty-two or more games, and established a strikeout record of 267, that lasted until 1961 when Sandy Koufax recorded 269 strikeouts.

     But you can't really talk about the Giants pitching without talking (or raving) about Joe McGinnity.
     First, in 1903, he pitched a whopping four hundred and thirty four innings, completing forty-four of his forty eight starts. He is the only pitcher to win thirty games while losing twenty in the same season. He remains the only pitcher to collect complete game wins in both games of a double-header three times in a season. Oh, and he did that within a month. He pitched one hundred innings during the month of August
     He was also the second pitcher to steal home plate in a game.

     Joe McGinnity pitched just ten years in the major Leagues, where he averaged twenty-five wins, forty-seven starts, thirty-four complete games, and three hundred forty-four innings per year.
Because of his durability, his endurance, work ethic, combined with the fact that he worked in an iron foundry, he earned the nickname “Iron Man”.
      Joe played for the aforementioned Baltimore Orioles, when it was a National League team in 1899, only to have that team contracted, and Joe was assigned to Brooklyn, where he pitched in 1900.
In 1901, after contract disputes and player raids from the upstart American League almost led to Joe's retirement, he signed with Baltimore, where he was teammates (again) with John McGraw.
     The style of baseball played by McGraw was very aggressive, and led to many altercations during (and often after) games. During one such spat, McGinnity spat on an umpire in a game in Detroit, and was arrested and immediately suspended by AL President Ban Johnson. That suspension would last twelve days, after McGinnity publicly apologized for his actions. John McGraw would soon resign from the Orioles, and sign on to manage the New York Giants.
     The Orioles franchise were facing serious financial difficulties, and were actually running the ball-club with a serious debt. As such, they were forced to release several of their players because they were unable to pay their salaries. Joe was released, and signed with the Giants immediately.
     Joe owned, played, and managed a few minor and semi-pro teams after his big league career ended. Pitching for the Dubuque Climbers in the Mississippi Valley League at the age of fifty-two, he won fifteen games. One of those was a shutout that lasted one hour and seven minutes.
     Because of his nickname, and with John McGraw understanding general showmanship, McGinnity was selected to start in an exhibition game in Birmingham, Alabama, against the Birmingham Iron Men in March of 1904. The game was scheduled to help raise funds to build a Vulcan statue for the Louisiana Purchase Centennial exhibition, which was at the World's fair in St. Louis.
     At his behest, Joe was allowed to visit the foundry in downtown Birmingham, and to personally pour some of the iron into the molds for the statue.
     That statue is the largest cast-iron statue in the world, and is still standing in Birmingham.


     He was elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame in 1946 by the Veteran's Committee.

     So, on to the season.
     The Boston Americans won their pennant handily, beating the second place Philadelphia Athletics by fourteen and a half games. The Pirates won their pennant by six and a half over the Giants.
     The Americans won the first World Championship, five games to three. Jimmy Sebring of the Pirates became the first to homer in the World Series, hitting one off of Cy Young.

     First, we'll take a look at the American League pitching, which was the most dominant of the four categories that I use for my reference points. They outperformed their National League counterparts by 21.6%.
     Again, as with this era, I will use the Runs Allowed factor rather than the Earned Runs Allowed to calculate my statistical rankings, but I will include both numbers in the rankings for your perusal.
     First, the initial numbers:
Pitcher
Team
W-L
Runs
ERA
Cy Young
Boston
28-9
3.03
2.08
Earl Moore
Cleveland
20-8
3.20
1.74
Bill Bernhard
Cleveland
14-5
3.37
2.12
Bill Dineen
Boston
21-13
2.95
2.26
Willie Sudhoff
Browns
21-15
3.06
2.27
Rube Waddell
Athletics
21-16
3.03
2.44
Addie Joss
Cleveland
18-13
3.33
2.19
Ted Hughes
Boston
20-7
3.49
2.57
Bill Donovan
Detroit
17-16
3.05
2.29
Eddie Plank
Athletics
23-16
3.43
2.38

     And as compared to their team's average performances, we get:

Earl Moore
Above



Bill Bernhard
Above



Watty Lee
Washington
8-12
4.64
3.08
Willie Sudhoff
Above



Doc White
White Sox
17-16
3.57
2.13
Bill Donovan
Above



Addie Joss
Above



Roy Patterson
White Sox
15-15
3.66
2.70
Cy Young
Above



Rube Waddell
Above




     That brings our overall rankings to this:
Earl Moore
Bill Bernhard
Cy Young
Willie Sudhoff
Addie Joss
Bill Donovan
Rube Waddell
Bill Dineen
Doc White
Eddie Plank

     And now to look at the National League:

Pitcher
Team
W-L
Runs
ERA
Sam Leever
Pirates
25-7
3.10
2.06
Deacon Phillipe
Pirates
25-9
3.61
2.43
Christy Mathewson
Giants
30-13
3.34
2.26
Joe McGinnity
Giants
31-20
3.36
2.43
Noodles Hahn
Reds
22-12
3.80
2.52
Jake Weimer
Cubs
20-8
3.54
2.30
Jack Taylor
Cubs
21-14
3.95
2.45
Bob Wicker
Cardinals/Cubs
20-9
4.15
2.96
Jack Sutthoff
Reds
16-9
4.17
2.80
Ed Doheny
Pirates
16-8
4.93
3.19

     And against their teams, we get:

Tully Sparks
Phillies
11-15
3.96
2.72
Mordecai Brown
Cardinals
9-13
4.70
2.60
Noodles Hahn
Above



Chappie McFarland
Cardinals
9-19
5.23
3.07
Vic Willis
Boston Beaneaters
12-18
3.92
2.98
Sam Leever
Above



Deacon Phillipe
Above



Christy Mathewson
Above



Jake Sutthoff
Above



Oscar Jones
Brooklyn
19-14
4.41
2.94

     And that brings us our top National League pitchers as:
Sam Leever
Noodles Hahn
Deacon Phillipe
Tully Sparks
Christy Mathewson
Joe McGinnity
Jake Weimer
Mordecai Brown
Jack Taylor
Bob Wicker


     Now we'll look at the National League offense, where they had a 15.1% statistical advantage over their American League counterparts. Our initial numbers flesh out this way:

Hitter
Team
HR
RBI
AVG
SB
Honus Wagner
Pirates
5
101
.355
46
Fred Clarke
Pirates
5
70
.351
21
Mike Donlin
Reds
7
67
.351
26
Ginger Beaumont
Pirates
7
68
.381
23
Sam Mertes
Giants
7
104
.280
45
Jake Beckley
Reds
2
81
.327
23
Tommy Leach
Pirates
7
87
.298
22
Frank Chance
Cubs
2
81
.327
67
Roger Bresnahan
Giants
4
55
.350
34
Harry Steinfeldt
Reds
6
83
.312
13

     Then as compared to their teams performance, we get:

Patsy Donovan
Cardinals
0
39
.327
25
Fred Tenney
Boston
3
41
.313
21
Duff Cooley
Boston
1
70
.289
27
Sam Mertes
Above




Homer Smoot
Cardinals
4
49
.296
17
Frank Chance
Above




Jimmy Sheckard
Brooklyn
9
75
.332
67
Honus Wagner
Above




Fred Clarke
Above




Bill Keister
Phillies
3
63
.320
11

     That brings us this list of top National League batters:
Honus Wagner
Fred Clarke
Sam Mertes
Mike Donlin
Frank Chance
Roger Bresnahan
Jimmy Sheckard
Ginger Beaumont
Jake Beckley
Tommy Leach

     And the American League offensive leaders begin with :
    
Hitter
Team
HR
RBI
AVG
SB
Napoleon Lajoie
Cleveland
7
93
.344
21
Jimmy Collins
Boston
5
72
.296
23
Sam Crawford
Detroit
4
89
.335
18
Bill Bradley
Cleveland
6
68
.313
21
Buck Freeman
Boston
13
104
.287
5
Charlie Hickman
Cleveland
12
97
.295
14
Freddie Parent
Boston
4
80
.304
24
Kid Elberfeld
New York/Detroit
0
64
.301
22
Danny Green
Chicago
6
62
.309
29
Jimmy Williams
New York
3
82
.267
9

     And as matched to their team performances, we get:

Sam Crawford
Above




Napoleon Lajoie
Above




John Anderson
Browns
2
78
.284
16
Danny Green
Above




Kip Selbach
Washington
3
49
.251
20
Harry Davis
Athletics
6
55
.298
24
Bill Bradley
Above




Kid Elberfeld
Above




Socks Seybold
Athletics
8
84
.299
5
Jimmy Collins
Above





     So our top American League batters are:
Napoleon Lajoie
Sam Crawford
Jimmy Collins
Bill Bradley
Harry Davis
Socks Seybold
Kid Elberfeld
Danny Green
John Anderson
Charlie Hickman

     Which brings our top five player rankings in each league to:
American League
Napoleon Lajoie (Player of the Year)

Sam Crawford
Earl Moore (Pitcher of the Year)

Bill Bernhard
Cy Young

National League
Honus Wagner (Player of the Year)

Fred Clarke
Sam Leever (Pitcher of the Year)

Sam Mertes
Mike Donlin

     Since there was no post season awards distributed during this era, I will pretend there was. And since I am pretending, the above would have been my vote.



Saturday, December 10, 2016

1963, comings and goings...and perfection

     The 1963 season can be remembered for something old, something new.

     The Cleveland Indians played the Washington Senators in D.C. In what was Major League Baseball's 100,000th game.

     Stan “The Man” Musial decided to hang up his spikes at the end of the season, and move into the front office for the Cardinals as their Vice President. While in Cincinnati, local legend Pete Rose debuted with the Reds, earning the National League Rookie of the Year award at the season's end.

     The Dodgers atoned for their disappointing playoff loss to the Giants in 1962, to win the pennant fairly easily in 1963. They did win by six games, but the hard charging Cardinals won nineteen of twenty games during a late season run, and pulled within a game of the Dodgers, But the Dodgers swept the Cardinals in three games, and pulled away to win their eight pennant in seventeen years.

     Pitching carried the Dodgers to the World Series, led by Sandy Koufax, who went 25-5 with a 1.88 ERA and became the first National League pitcher to reach the 300 strikeout mark. They also got 19 wins from Don Drysdale, 16 wins from Ron Perranoski and 10 from Johnny Podres.

     The Dodgers were the first team to never trail in a game during the World Series.

     Koufax bettered his own strikeout record he established in 1961, and he shattered that by 37 strikeouts. Of course, that record was established in a season where there were more games played, 162 against 154. However, unlike the asterisk fiasco that haunted Roger Maris as he bested Babe Ruth's record in 1961, there was no talk whatsoever of an asterisk being assigned to Koufax's record. Whether that was due to office politics by the commissioner at the time, or the fact that Koufax obliterated his own record, or the fact that it was his own record, I don't know. But the asterisk debated seems to have only been directed at one record.

     Koufax, while winning the pitching 'triple crown', became the second pitcher to win the MVP and the Cy Young Award in the same year. The first to do so was his former teammate Don Newcombe in 1956.

    (As an aside, Newcombe served in the US Army and the US Navy, and remains the only US military veteran to win an MVP and Cy Young Award)

Tommy Davis of the Dodgers won his second straight batting title, batting .326.


There were four players during the 1963 season who were also NBA players. They were Gene Conley, Dick Groat, Steve Hamilton and NBA Hall of Famer Dave DeBusschere.






For the Cardinals, Bill White became the first National Leaguer to have both 200 hits and 100 strikeouts in the same season, while pitcher Curt Simmons became the first pitcher in eight seasons to steal home. It would be another twenty-one years before Pascual Perez became the next to do so.



Stan Musial may be the only player to accomplish this particular feat, as in hitting a home run after becoming a grandfather. His daughter-in-law gave birth on September 10th, and Musial homered in his first at bat that day against Glen Hobbie of the Cubs.


For the Mets, Jim Hickman hit for the cycle. Hitting for the cycle, in which the batter gets a single, double, triple and homer in the same game, is rarer than pitching a no-hitter. And even more scarce is a 'natural' cycle, in which the batters get the hits in the pre-described order. Jim Hickman became just the second National Leaguer to accomplish that feat.

For the Milwaukee Braves, lefty Warren Spahn was able to beat the Dodgers in Los Angeles for the first time. In fact it was the first time he had beaten the Dodgers as the visiting pitcher since 1948. Fifteen years.

The Giants fielded an all Alou outfield for one inning late in the season. Rookie Jesus joined his brothers Matty and Felipe in New York on September 10th. It was the first and only time that three siblings appeared on the field at the same time.

Carl Yastrzemski of the Red Sox became the first and only American Leaguer to lead the league in both hits and walks in the same season. Yaz led the league in hitting for the first of three times. His .321 was the 7th lowest average to lead the AL. (His .301 in 1968 is the lowest ever for a batting champ)

Minnie Minoso of the Senators became the oldest player to hit a Grand Slam home run, a record that was later broken by Henry Blanco (twice).

And speaking of Senator homers, Don Leppert hit 3 homers in a game against the Red Sox in April. He wound up hitting 3 more that season, setting the record for the lowest amount of homers in a season by someone with 3 in one game.

In Minnesota, Harmon Killebrew set the record for the most homers (45) by a player that didn't drive in 100 runs (96) in a season.

In Baltimore, Steve Barber became the first Oriole pitcher to win 20 games in a season, while Luis Aparicio became the first Oriole to lead the league in Stolen Bases.


With the selection of Elston Howard, the Yankees had their fourth straight MVP. (Roger Maris twice, then Yogi Berra before Howard)


Duke Snider, a.k.a. The Duke of Flatbush,hit his 400th career home run as a member of the New York Mets. This fact barely got a mention in the New York newspapers. As the story goes, outfielder Jimmy Piersall had hit 99 in his career, and bet Snider that his 100th home run would get headlines across the country. facing Phillies pitcher, and future Mets manager Dallas Green, Piersal connected on his 100th homer, his only homer as a Met, and ran around the bases backwards. true to his word to Snider, his 100th made headlines in all the sports pages. The fame was short-lived, as he was released by the Mets about a month later. 

In Houston, the Astros unveiled an All-Rookie lineup against the Mets. Jerry Grote, Rusty Staub, Joe Morgan, Sonny Jackson, Glenn Vaughan, Brock Davis, Jimmy Wynn and Jay Dahl were the starting nine.

And speaking of the Astros, perfection happened in a manner that will probably never be seen again. Rookie John Paciorek started in a game against against those same Mets on September 29th. He walked in his first at-bat,then singled, singled again, walked again, and then singled for the third and last time.
He never made another appearance in a major league game, suffering from several injuries including a sciatic nerve injury, which led to eventual spinal fusion surgery.. He has a perfect 1.000 batting average and on base percentage. He is the only player to have a 1.000 batting average with more than one at-bat. And, during the game (a 13-4 Astro win) he scored 4 runs, giving him an average of 4.0 runs created per game. (for your reference, Babe Ruth had a 1.47 runs created per game average)


So, on to the season at hand. We'll look at the American League offense first. The basic numbers leaders were..
Player
Team
HR
RBI
AVG
Elston Howard
Yankees
28
85
0.29
Al Kaline
Tigers
27
101
.312
Bobby Allison
Twins
35
91
.271
Harmon Killebrew
Twins
45
96
.258
Earl Battey
Twins
26
84
.285
Carl Yastrzemski
Red Sox
14
68
.321
Dick Stuart
Red Sox
42
118
.261
Tom Tresh
Yankees
25
71
.269
Rocky Colavito
Tigers
22
91
.271
Norm Siebern
A's
16
83
.272

And then, as compared to their team's performances, our rankings are:

Elston Howard
Above



Al Kaline
Above



Don Lock
Senators
27
82
.252
Carl Yastrzemski
Above



Leon Wagner
Angels
26
90
.291
Dick Stuart
Above



Chuck Hinton
Senators
15
55
.269
Norm Siebern
Above



Albie Pearson
Angels
6
47
.304
Bobby Allison




So factoring in the figures, our top ten in the AL is:

Elston Howard
AL MVP
Al Kaline
2nd in MVP
Carl Yastrzemski
6th in MVP
Bobby Allison
15th in MVP
Dick Stuart
13th in MVP
Leon Wagner
19th in MVP
Harmon Killebrew
4th in MVP
Norm Siebern
27th in MVP
Tom Tresh
11th in MVP
Don Lock
No votes



And the in the National League, we start with this list:

Player
Team
HR
RBI
AVG
Hank Aaron
Braves
44
130
.319
Willie Mays
Giants
38
103
.314
Bill White
Cardinals
27
109
.304
Orlando Cepeda
Giants
34
97
.316
Vada Pinson
Reds
22
106
.313
Willie McCovey
Giants
44
102
.280
Ken Boyer
Cardinals
24
111
.285
Frank Robinson
Reds
21
91
.259
Billy Williams
Cubs
25
95
.283
Curt Flood
Cardinals
5
63
.302

And against their team's average performance, we get this list:

Hank Aaron
Above



Billy Williams
Above



Ron Santo
Cubs
25
99
.297
Willie Mays
Above



Vada Pinson
Above



Roberto Clemente
Pirates
17
76
.320
Frank Robinson
Above



Al Spangler
Astros
4
27
.281
Orlando Cepeda
Above



Willie McCovey
Above








Adding, figuring and ciphering, brings this list of top ten National League offensive performers for 1963:
Hank Aaron 3rd in MVP
Willie Mays 5th in MVP
Vada Pinson 10th in MVP
Billy Williams No votes
Orlando Cepeda No votes
Willie McCovey 17th in MVP
Ron Santo 8th in MVP
Frank Robinson No votes
Bill White 7th in MVP
Roberto Clemente 14th in MVP


Now, we'll look at the pitching, which was very strong across both leagues. How strong, you ask? The National League pitchers out performed the hitters by 35.7%, while the American league bested their hitters by 21.5%, statistically speaking of course. The low batting averages and low RBI numbers bear this out. Both leagues combined to average scoring just 3.9 runs per game.

Wit that being said, we'll look at the American League first, with the raw numbers being:

Pitcher
Team
W-L
ERA
Saves
Camilo Pascual
Twins
21-9
2.46

Whitey Ford
Yankees
24-7
2.74

Juan Pizarro
White Sox
16-8
2.39

Al Dowling
Yankees
13-5
2.56

Jim Bouton
Yankees
21-7
2.53

Gary Peters
White Sox
19-8
2.33

Dick Radatz
Red Sox
15-6
1.97
23
Steve Barber
Orioles
20-13
2.75

Jack Kralick
Twins/Indians
14-13
3.03

Bill Dailey
Twins
6-3
1.99
21

And against their team performances, we get...

Dick Radatz
Above



Camilo Pascual
Above



Ron Kline
Senators
3-8
2.79
17
Jack Kralick
Above



Bill Monboquette
Red Sox
20-10
3.81

Claude Osteen
Senators
9-14
3.35

Whitey Ford
Above



Juan Pizarro
Above



Gary Peters
Above



Steve Barber
Above




That brings our top AL pitchers to this result...(Bear in mind, at this point in baseball history, there was only one Cy Young Award handed out each season, and in 1963, Sandy Koufax was the unanimous winner)
Camilo Pascual No votes
Jack Kralick No votes
Dick Radatz 5th in MVP
Whitey Ford 3rd in MVP
Juan Pizarro No votes
Al Dowling No votes
Jim Bouton 16th in MVP
Gary Peters 8th in MVP, ROOKIE OF THE YEAR
Steve Barber No votes
Bill Monboquette No votes


The National League brings us this following list, raw numbers first:
Pitcher
Team
W-L
ERA
Saves
Sandy Koufax
Dodgers
25-5
1.88

Dick Ellsworth
Cubs
22-10
2.11

Warren Spahn
Braves
23-7
2.60

Jim Maloney
Reds
23-7
2.77

Juan Marichal
Giants
25-8
2.41

Ron Perranoski
Dodgers
16-3
1.67
21
Bob Friend
Pirates
17-16
2.34

Curt Simmons
Cardinals
15-9
2.48

Joe Nuxhall
Reds
15-8
2.61

Jim O'Toole
Reds
17-14
2.88


And then against their teams averages. This is I believe a good way to find stellar performers that may be overlooked by their team's less than stellar record. I say that because two Mets pitchers make the list, for a team that lost 111 games:

Carlton Willey
Mets
9-14
3.10

Warren Spahn
Above



Dick Ellsworth
Above



Jim Maloney
Above



Sandy Koufax
Above



Hal Woodeshick
Astros
11-9
1.97
10
Juan Marichal
Above



Turk Farrell
Astros
14-13
3.02

Al Jackson
Mets
13-17
3.96

Bob Friend
Above




Which gives us the top pitcher rankings as follows:



Sandy Koufax Cy Young, NL MVP
Warren Spahn 12th in MVP
Dick Ellsworth 19th in MVP (tie)
Jim Maloney 19th in MVP (tie)
Juan Marichal 11th in MVP
Bob Friend No votes
Hal Woodeshick No votes
Curt Simmons No votes
Carlton Willey No votes
Turk Farrell No votes


So, for our top players in each league, if I were to have had a vote back in the day, my American League vote would be:

Elston Howard
Al Kaline
Camilo Pascual
Carl Yastrzemski
Bobby Allison

And in the National League, it would be:

Hank Aaron
Sandy Koufax
Willie Mays
Warren Spahn
Vada Pinson